Steaks & BeefSteak

Rump, Sirloin or Ribeye: A Home Cook's Buying Order

Sirloin vs ribeye vs rump steak compared by a butcher: flavour, tenderness, fat, price per kg and the best way to cook each, so you can pick the right steak.

4 min read
Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz

Updated 30 September 2026

Sirloin vs ribeye is the question we get asked more than any other, closely followed by where rump fits in. All three are great steaks; they just suit different people, budgets and cooking methods. This guide compares rump, sirloin and ribeye on flavour, tenderness, fat and price, and tells you how to cook each so you get the best from it.

Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz
Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz, £10.49

Shop Ribeye Steaks

Quick answer: choose ribeye for the juiciest, richest steak; sirloin for a tender, balanced all-rounder with a strip of fat; and rump for the most beefy flavour for the money, with a firmer bite.

Rump vs sirloin vs ribeye at a glance

Ribeye Sirloin Rump
Where it comes from The rib The back, between rib and rump The hip
Tenderness Very tender Tender Firmer, more chew
Fat Marbled through, with a fat "eye" Strip of fat along one edge, leaner meat Lean, with a little fat on the edge
Flavour Rich, buttery, beefy Clean, classic steak flavour Big, deep, beefy
Best cooked Medium-rare to medium Rare to medium Rare to medium-rare
Best method Hot pan, grill, BBQ Pan, grill, BBQ Very hot pan or grill, sliced thin

Ribeye vs sirloin: which is better?

Neither is better; they are different.

Ribeye comes from the rib section. It has fat marbled right through the meat and a little pocket of fat near the centre, which melts as it cooks and keeps the steak juicy. That makes ribeye the most forgiving steak to cook and the richest to eat. The trade-off is that some people find the fat too much, and it is usually a little dearer.

Sirloin sits behind the ribs. The meat itself is leaner than ribeye, with a band of fat along one edge rather than running through it. That gives you a tender, cleaner-tasting steak, and you can eat as much or as little of the fat as you like. It is the classic British steak for good reason.

So, sirloin vs ribeye in one line: if you want juicy and rich, pick ribeye; if you want tender and a bit leaner, pick sirloin.

Where rump fits in

Rump comes from the hip, a muscle that does more work, so it is firmer than sirloin or ribeye. What it loses in tenderness it gains in flavour: many butchers consider rump the tastiest of the three. It is also the best value. Cook rump rare to medium-rare, rest it well and slice it across the grain, and it eats beautifully. Overcook it and it gets chewy.

Price per kg

Here is how the three compare on our live prices, worked out per kilo so you can compare like with like.

Steak Pack price Price per kg
Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz £10.49 about £30.85
Sirloin Steak 2x 8oz £11.99 about £26.41
Rump Steak 2x 6oz £8.99 about £26.44

Prices checked 30 September 2026 (6oz is 170g and 8oz is 227g); the price on each product page is the one you pay. For multi-packs, see Ribeye Steaks 8x6oz (£38.99) and Rump Steak 8x 6oz (£28.99). Our steak prices UK guide lists every pack.

Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz

Rib-eye Steak 2x 6oz

£10.49

Shop now

Sirloin Steak 2x 8oz

Sirloin Steak 2x 8oz

£11.99

Shop now

Rump Steak 2x 6oz

Rump Steak 2x 6oz

£8.99

Shop now

Ribeye Steaks 8x6oz

Ribeye Steaks 8x6oz

£38.99

Shop now

How to cook each steak

All three start the same way: take the steak out of the fridge 30 minutes before cooking, pat it dry, season with salt and get the pan smoking hot. Then:

  • Ribeye: cook it a touch longer than you would a sirloin so the marbling melts: 3–4 minutes a side for medium-rare on a 2.5cm steak. Render the fat edge by holding it in the pan with tongs. See how to cook ribeye steak.
  • Sirloin: 2½–3 minutes a side for medium-rare on a 2.5cm steak. Start it fat-edge down for a minute to crisp the fat. See how to cook sirloin steak.
  • Rump: very high heat, 2–3 minutes a side for rare to medium-rare, rest for at least 5 minutes and slice thinly across the grain. See how to cook rump steak.

Rest every steak for about half its cooking time. The Food Standards Agency says whole cuts of beef, such as steaks, can be served pink as long as the outside is properly cooked.

Which steak should you buy?

  • For a special steak night: ribeye, or fillet if you want the most tender cut of all.
  • For a classic steak and chips: sirloin.
  • For flavour on a budget, stir-fries and steak sandwiches: rump.
  • For the barbecue: ribeye, because the marbling copes with high heat.
  • For people who do not like fat: sirloin, with the fat trimmed after cooking, or fillet.
  • For a family: multi-packs of sirloin or rump go furthest.

Still undecided? The Classic Steak Trio Box (£32.99) gives you rib-eye, rump and sirloin in one box so you can taste all three side by side. For every other cut, read types of steak, or browse all our steaks, sirloin steaks and rump steaks.

Sirloin vs ribeye FAQs

Is ribeye or sirloin more tender?

Ribeye is usually slightly more tender and juicier because of its marbling. Sirloin is also tender but leaner, with its fat on the edge rather than through the meat.

Which is healthier, sirloin or ribeye?

Sirloin is leaner, especially with the fat edge trimmed, so it has less fat per 100g than ribeye.

Is rump steak as good as sirloin?

Rump has more flavour but a firmer texture. Cooked rare to medium-rare and sliced across the grain, it is excellent, and it costs less per kilo than sirloin or ribeye on most counters.

Which steak is best for a beginner?

Ribeye, because its marbling keeps it juicy even if it is cooked a little longer than planned.

Why is ribeye more expensive than sirloin?

There is less ribeye per animal, and its marbling and tenderness make it one of the most sought-after steaks.

Shop Steaks

  • Trusted by over 150,000 shoppers
  • Free weekday delivery over £85
  • Online butcher based in Cornwall
  • Skip the middle man!

From UK Recipes

See all 169

Shop the cuts

Cut by our butchers, sent chilled to your door. Skip the middle man!

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published.